Not-so-full disclosure
The Boston Globe op-ed page today carries a column that criticizes the National Education Association's endorsement of a union campaign to boycott Wal-Mart. The piece was written by Michael Reitz, whom the Globe identifies as "the director of the Labor Policy Center for the Evergreen Freedom Foundation, a nonpartisan, public policy research organization based in Olympia, Wash."
Among other things, Reitz charges, "The NEA even criticizes the Walton family, the founders of Wal-Mart, for contributing to 'anti-public education efforts like private school voucher initiatives and anti-public educations PACs.'"
Unfortunately, you will not be surprised to learn that the Globe - and not for the first time - has failed to perform due diligence with respect to an outside op-ed contributor. In five minutes of Googling, I was able to learn that the Evergreen Freedom Foundation (EFF) is anything but "a nonpartisan, public policy research organization." And it turns out to be no surprise that the foundation is particularly exercised about Wal-Mart.
Here is a 2002 article posted on the website Media Transparency, which tracks "the money behind conservative media." Although I wish the data were a little more up to date, I think it's sufficient to prove EFF's hyperpartisan nature. Here are three major donors to the EFF that should help to establish Reitz's bona fides:
1. The Walton Family Foundation, which is the charitable arm of - yes - the Wal-Mart fortune left behind by the late founder, Sam Walton. According to Media Transparency, the foundation gave Evergreen $300,000 between 1998 and 2000, and has also given millions to other groups that support EFF's conservative education agenda, such as tuition vouchers. No wonder Reitz expressed such shock and horror that the NEA "even criticizes the Walton family."
2. The Sarah Scaife Foundation, controlled by the notorious right-wing financier Richard Mellon Scaife. The Scaife Foundation, Media Transparency discovered, gave Evergreen $150,000 from 1998 to 2000.
3. Boston business figure William Edgerly. In light of Tom Palmer's eye-opening piece about the Pioneer Institute's woes - published in the Globe Ideas section this past Sunday - the following excerpt from Media Transparency's report is pretty interesting:
MEDIA TRANSPARENCY: Foundation for Partnerships Trust, funded and run by William Edgerly, CEO emeritus of State Street Bank and Trust of Boston. The foundation gave Evergreen a total of $70,000 in 1998 and 1999; at the time of the grant, Edgerly was chairman of Advantage Schools, a for-profit school operator run by former Pioneer Institute executive director Steve Wilson that clashed with the Massachusetts Education Association over operation of schools in the state. Edgerly is on the board of the Pioneer Institute, a Massachusetts member of the State Policy Network.Weitz's success in placing his anti-NEA screed in the Globe was something of a coup for Evergreen: it currently leads the "What's New" page on the organization's website. And so the Globe has provided Evergreen with some undeserved credibility.
From time to time, the Globe's policy of accepting paid advocacy ads for the op-ed page comes under fire, even though such distinguished papers as its corporate big brother, the New York Times, do the same thing. On July 21, for instance, the Boston Herald tweaked the Globe for its efforts to market that valuable real estate.
But at least with an ad, you know what you're getting. Running Reitz's Evergreen piece was far more insidious, because the reader was given no warning about the agenda behind the op-ed. Needless to say, full disclosure should have been provided. But I suspect that the Globe editors would rather have killed the piece than admit it was funded with money from the likes of Wal-Mart and Scaife.



21 Comments:
Technically, the Globe is right. Evergreen is a "nonpartisan, public policy research organization based in Olympia, Wash." As a charity, Evergreen is legally barred from endorsing or supporting any particular candidate or party -- which makes it nonpartisan. The second part of the phrase is just longhand for thinktank.
The problem with the label is it isn't very description. Almost all thinktanks can call themselves "nonpartisan public policy research organizations." But some are liberal. Some are conservative. Some are all over the place. Evergreen makes no bones about the fact that it supports limited government and the free market. That's its main purpose. And Globe readers deserve to know that.
Good Lord. Romenesko links to this item today, giving it headline treatment and once again ignoring the barrage of similarly themed pieces from the right end of the political spectrum.
Every day, conservative and libertarian pundits/critics/bloggers/etc. point out stuff like this, both egregious and not-so. Such right-side criticism is everywhere on the Web, and is certainly far more extensive than its leftist counterpart. Yet Romenesko inexplicably spotlights this lone item directed at an innocuous op-ed in a Boston paper, an item grounded in "five minutes of Googling."
The saddest part is that so many journalists visit Romenesko believing it to be a straight-ahead clearinghouse for "media industry news" and commentary. And so the contemporary media's fatal march -- through the echo chamber, into the cocoon, pick-your-metaphor -- goes on.
Okay, then, please post examples and let everyone judge.
Its interesting that The Globe didn't check things out. A very good friend of mine just had a letter to the editor printed by The Globe, but without the Globe calling to verify that she was the actual author. That's standard procedure at every paper I've ever worked at.
- David Wilson
". . . the Globe's coporate big brother, the New York Times . . .". Excuse me, but The Times is not the Globe's "big brother"--it is the Globe's owner, which any younger brother can tell you is not the same thing.
Cute is fine except when it befogs the truth.
Re: Whether the NYT is a big brother or owner of the Globe: Technically, big brother is correct. It's the New York Times Co. that owns the Globe, and it owns the New York Times, too. Both newspapers are owned by the company.
As soon as I got halfway through that article, I smelled something piscatorial and it wasn't coming from the Boston Fish Pier. I glanced at the author's vitals at the end of the story. As soon as I saw "non-partisan .... research center" I knew this was BS. I didn't even need to google the name.
One could argue that the end note ID'ng Evergreen is sufficient because those types of brief IDs are standard practice on op-ed pages with scarce, precious space. What a crock! By failing to give readers an honest accounting of this outfit's identity, it allows someone with a clear ideological bias to hide behind the cloak of "non-partisanship." The fact that the Walton family is one of their major funders compounds the infraction. The SCLM Globe's op-ed editors show that they take their readers for fools and/or despise the teachers' union so much that they don't mind letting a dubious organization perpetuate a fraud to take a shot at them.
The problem with the individuals who are so incensed that Evergreen Freedom Foundation managed to secure a bit of ink to rebut the NEA's endorsement of a Wal-Mart boycott is that the incensed individuals don't know the meaning of the word "nonpartisan." Hint: it does not mean "neutral."
Dan Miller
"For many years, we provided a complete list of Heartland’s corporate and foundation donors on this Web site and challenged other think tanks and advocacy groups to do the same. To our knowledge, not a single group followed our lead."
Is this correct?
What would be the most feasible and effective standard for Op-Ed disclosures, and how could it be implemented?
(I want to see it implemented for regular columnists too.)
Anna in Calif
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
A very good friend of mine just had a letter to the editor printed by The Globe, but without the Globe calling to verify that she was the actual author.
The Globe has printed several letters from me in the last couple years* and I don't remember ever being contacted to confirm.
Mind you, I do follow their guidelines and include my street address and phone number below the email, so presumably they at least confirm that I'm a real Massachusetts resident. Or maybe they've already got me on file somewhere as a legit correspondent.
Regardless, the only way I know whether the Globe prints my letters is by seeing them in the paper.
In most cases, the Globe has edited my letters -- usually minor grammatical changes, but they've also truncated what I sent them -- without reviewing those with me either. [If they had, maybe I could've prevented them from introducing an error to my last missive.]
The fact the Globe edits letters without notifying the sender was probably most prominently spotlighted by the case of Eric Alterman back in February
*Aug 2003, June 2004, last month
The problem is not that the organization is actually technically "non-partisan," it is that describing it as such creates a misimpression in the mind of the reader. The organization in question is not an academic one. It does not submit any of its thinktankery for peer review or similar scrutiny. Its writer's salary is paid in part by entity he's defending. It is bad journalism to allow such nonsense to appear in a newspaper with no additional explanation.
This is just a tiny example of America's omni-present right-wing bullS#!t machine. Billions of dollars have been spent over the years to pay the salaries of guys in "think-tanks" and for unprofitable publishing houses and magazines. So we get the pathetic irony of this or that conservative "intellectual" on tv or in print extolling the virtues of hard work and free enterprise even as he or she clings to the pasty teet of, say, Richard Mellon-Scaife (or Rupert Murdoch or the Koch family).
Speaking of researching funding…guess who invests in Wal-Mart stock as part of their pension? None other than the Teachers’ Union located in Washington State with the EFF. Talk about lack of disclosure concerning the union's boycott of Wal-Mart. While the teachers are asking us to boycott shopping there I doubt they'll boycott their pension payments. Details here: http://www2.icmarc.org/xp/plan3/trs/investing/funds/lgstock-index.xml#topten
http://www.sib.wa.gov/financial/pdfs/annual/ar04.pdf
(Retirement Funds can be found on page 71 of pdf.)
(Labor and Industries’ Funds can be found on page 103 and 109.)
I've had a letter to the editor printed recently and was not called either. But I'm a subscriber AND I'm registered with the boston.com/globe web site.
The issue at hand is not "partisanship," it's "transparency."
This is, of course, an important point, like many of the points presented in this thread.
But most folks of the conservative persuasion would laugh heartily -- or heartily laugh, if they're copy editors -- at the indignation oozing from all these comments. The right has to deal with this kind of stuff, and far worse, every day in the major media. Shelves of books have been written on the topic, as you all know.
Here you get one questionable description of a think tank -- a single word written by a liberal editorial department -- and you're instantly up to your ears in self-righteousness and Romenesko links.
Amazing.
Er, I think you're missing the point, which is about the media, not Wal-Mart.
As for the EFF being a “sockpuppet” for Wal-Mart, it looks like the EFF doesn’t have much love for corporate welfare or tax subsidies:
State tax exemptions survived this session
http://seattlepi.nwsource.com/local/224369_gtax16.html
Potential agencies and programs to eliminate
http://www.effwa.org/main/article.php?article_id=801
The Boeing contract and the state's Constitution
http://www.effwa.org/main/article.php?article_id=237
Hopefully their masters at Wal-Mart are paying attention to the EFF’s actions; EFF must have missed their marching orders.
I'm with Todd - EFF, which I was familiar with when I worked in Seattle, is technically nonpartisan, but of course they're conservative. They don't like the NEA in the first place, and they don't like high spending in Washington State, where most of their energies are directed. The place is based in Olympia, not far from the state capitol building. So I'm having trouble understanding why you're so peeved - would you demand the same laborious background for an op-ed contributor funded by, say, George Soros? As Seinfeld's Kramer would say, "He's a sweet kid!" This stuff is pretty typical, Dan.
Reviewing the info from media transparency, it looks like EFF received funding from the Walton Foundation in 2002. How does a grant from 2002 equate to Wal-Mart (versus Walton Foundation) paying EFF to write the oped from yesterday's Globe?
Zenegra
Stop4rx
Cialis
Tadalafil
Generic Cialis
Viagra
Generic Viagra
Tadalafil Cialis
buy cialis
buy Viagra
Zenegra
Stop4rx
Cialis
Tadalafil
Generic Cialis
Viagra
Generic Viagra
Tadalafil Cialis
buy cialis
buy Viagra
Zenegra
Stop4rx
Cialis
Tadalafil
Generic Cialis
Viagra
Generic Viagra
Tadalafil Cialis
buy cialis
buy Viagra
Zenegra
Stop4rx
Cialis
Tadalafil
Generic Cialis
Viagra
Generic Viagra
Tadalafil Cialis
buy cialis
buy Viagra
Post a Comment
<< Home